Soon, I will have a minor influx of money which will allow me to choose between 2 similar cruises offered by 2 different cruise lines. The first cruise will be a 5-day cruise on Virgin Voyages between New York and Bermuda. It will arrive in Bermuda at 4 pm, and leave at 4 pm the next day. The second cruise will also be a 5-day cruise on Norwegian Cruise Lines between the same ports, both departing and returning 1 day later. This cruise will arrive in Bermuda at 8 an and leave at 3 pm the next day. Which cruise will I take?
Examining the 2 cruise itineraries, Virgin's cruise spends several hours less in Bermuda than NCL's cruise. Is that the only difference? When I ran the numbers for the add-ons I'd purchase for each cruise, Virgin's cruise comes in with a price a few dollars more than that of NCL's cruise. However, Virgin serves better food than NCL does. Even when I factor in the specialty meals I'd get on an NCL cruise, I'd choose Virgin over NCL in this area. But food isn't my only consideration. The extra time I'd get in Bermuda on an NCL cruise allows me to get to St. George on Bermuda's other end - for free, if I use NCL's ferry.
What I haven't mention so far is loyalty status. If I take the Virgin cruise, I won't accumulate much. I'd have to reach the equivalent of 5 cruises to get an extra specialty coffee and a $100 bar tab per cruise. However, on NCL, I'd get an extra water container after 1 more cruise. (I'm at Platinum level, and I get the free bag of laundry already.) Big deal! Virgin does not have any more cruises scheduled to sail from New York after this fall, while NCL makes New York one of its home ports. I don't add much to loyalty status by taking either cruise. The next level of NCL loyalty status will be easier for me to achieve. But I would get more on Virgin - if I choose to fly to Florida for one of their cruises.
So, which cruise will I choose? In a week, I should have the money that I'll use for this cruise. One cruise sails out of Brooklyn (Virgin), while the other sails out of Manhattan (NCL). It is easier for me to reach the Manhattan cruise terminal than the one in Brooklyn. Yet, I'm not sure of what I will do I'll let you know when I make the decision.




